US House passes BS legislation on gas prices.
Your government at work folks… they know you’re dependant and they’re going to capitalize on it.
The House of Representatives passed a bill yesterday that would make “price gouging” at the pump a FEDERAL CRIME.
This bill will do ABSOLUTELY NOTHING to lower the price of gas at the pump, and in fact could in turn worsen the problem.
Price gouging laws are pure price control and in a free market system, artificial price restrictions cause severe issues. When you have a depressed supply chain and an increased demand in industrialized countries (not JUST the US) you’re going to see an increase in prices. When you put your hand in the pot and your supply/demand variables do not change, you’re going to create an environment that will encourage runs on the product and in the long run you will cause severe damage to your supply, jacking up prices even more.
The other problem with laws like these is that they always seem to be extremely vague. Take this latest bill for example, price gouging is defined as “when the price is ‘unconscionably excessive’ or ‘indicates that the seller is taking unfair advantage of unusual market conditions.’”. Well THAT sure clears up the muddy water now doesn’t it.
So let’s see, $3.79 a gallon would be unconscionable excessive to whom? I know I wouldn’t like paying $3.79 a gallon for gas, but I also know that every single one of those politicians who are telling me it’s unfair can afford that without blinking an eye. So excessive for whom? Let’s say the price of gas makes it all the way to $5 a gallon… now that IS excessive… but is it unconscionable if the market demanded that price to curb the overdraw on supply?
Now, on to the “unfair advantage” clause. Just what is an unfair advantage? Lets say a huge earthquake rocks an area of the US, effectively destroying over 95% of the access into an area. ONE station is able to receive fuel shipments and as the nature of S/D would have it, in order to curb runs on their VERY limited supply. As such, he prices his gas @ $15 a gallon so that only people that REALLY need access to fuel will buy it. Under this new bill… this station owner by sheer luck of natural forces is taking an “unfair advantage” of unusual market conditions thus making him a criminal because of his situation.
This law would force this station owner to fix his prices at or below the market average, thus unleashing desparate people into his limited supply, essentially wiping out the fuel supply and potentially putting him out of business.
Seem very fair to you?

Greg
24 May, 2007
Living in the San Francisco Bay Area where an earthquake of such magnitude to destroy access points, I think that even if the price of gas went up to $15/gal. you’d have wealthy folks filling up their gas-guzzling Hummers to drive to work or do whatever else they do—one person to a vehicle. Meanwhile, the poor folks would be left out in the cold. So to that point, I don’t really agree that the gas would only go to those who REALLY needed it, but to those that could afford it.
So, to answer your question, what DOESN’T seem very fair is that wealthy people who don’t really care about how much gas costs will buy it no matter the price.
I think the gas companies routinely gouge us on the price of gas. Within one day the price can jump 35 cents, but it can take a few months for the price to come back down, if it even does come back down. Personally, I don’t like being gouged, especially for a product that we all need to use.
If they want to make something illegal, maybe they should make it illegal to buy a “truck” that only drives 10 miles to the gallon.
James
24 May, 2007
Personally, I don’t like being gouged, especially for a product that we all need to use.
So would you be fine with someone charging anything they so desire for a candybar, but economically damaging legislation set on gas because you NEED it? The free market system doesn’t pick and choose how it works based on the product… why should the government step in?
So, to answer your question, what DOESN’T seem very fair is that wealthy people who don’t really care about how much gas costs will buy it no matter the price.
You don’t think it’s FAIR that someone with money can spend it the way they want? If I have a million bucks, and I want to buy gold plate my Hummer, should I be allowed to? After all… that wouldn’t be FAIR to the homeless guy down the street.